91制片厂视频

Includes updates and/or revisions.

When 16 finalists come to Washington next week to make their final pitches in the $4 billion Race to the Top competition, most can expect to go home empty-handed.

U.S. Secretary of 91制片厂视频 Arne Duncan, in announcing last week, said that no more than $2 billion will be divided among 鈥渧ery few winners鈥� when the awards are given out in April鈥攁nd said 鈥渕ost鈥� would not be victorious.

鈥淭hese are the 16 best applications we received. Winning will require excellence,鈥� Mr. Duncan said in a conference call with reporters.

The finalists from among 41 first-round applicants are: Colorado, Delaware, the District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, and Tennessee.

The $4 billion available for individual state grants under the Race to the Top Fund鈥攁 sliver of the $787 billion economic-stimulus package passed by Congress early last year鈥攊s paying for a high-profile school reform initiative that鈥檚 helping drive the Obama administration鈥檚 education agenda.

The awards will come as many states continue to claw their way out of a deep fiscal pit and face the prospect of stinging cuts to programs, including K-12 education. The highly coveted awards will also be given out during the pivotal 2010 election season, when 37 states will elect governors. Eleven of the finalist states will see gubernatorial races this year, and the District of Columbia has a mayor鈥檚 race.

The dash for cash鈥攁nd bragging rights鈥攑rompted states to embark on aggressive lobbying campaigns to change laws to be more competitive under the 500-point scoring scale used to weigh the applications. Some lifted caps on charter schools, tore down data 鈥渇irewalls鈥� standing in the way of new systems of teacher evaluation, and devised strategies to intervene in more low-performing schools.

鈥淢ost of the states that really did bold things in the spirit of the competition generally made it through,鈥� said Timothy Daly, the president of the New Teacher Project, a New York City-based nonprofit group that helps urban districts train and hire teachers.

One example: Illinois is among a handful of states to require all districts, not just those participating in the Race to the Top, to use student achievement as at least 50 percent of an individual teacher鈥檚 evaluation.

Lengthy List

Many policy experts were surprised at the length of the finalist list, particularly after Secretary Duncan had promised鈥攊n an interview with 91制片厂视频 Week and elsewhere鈥攖hat he would set a 鈥渧ery, very high bar鈥� for the competition. The finalists represent more than one-third of the applications submitted.

鈥淚 can鈥檛 see how this advances the reform agenda by rewarding states for putting out average applications,鈥� said Andy Smarick, a visiting fellow with the Washington-based Thomas B. Fordham Institute. He pointed out that Kentucky doesn鈥檛 have charter schools, and that Colorado and New York are weak on teacher-evaluation components, factors that would have been weighed in the scoring. 鈥淭hat sends a message to other states that you can bypass tough decisions.鈥�

But Mr. Duncan said that he favored giving more states, rather than fewer, a shot at the money. Each of the finalists earned a grade of at least a B on its application, scoring above 400 points on a complex 500-point grading scale that measured each state鈥檚 blueprint for education improvement and, specifically, its commitment to improving teacher effectiveness, data systems, academic standards, and low-performing schools.

In essence, Mr. Duncan said that the scores are close enough among the Final 16 that 鈥渁ll of these states can win.鈥�

What matters to Todd Ziebarth of the National Alliance for Public 91制片厂视频 Schools is just that: who wins in April. He said five states are complete 鈥渃lunkers鈥� when it comes to charter schools, either because they don鈥檛 have charters at all (in Kentucky鈥檚 case) or because they have restrictive caps on the growth of the publicly financed but largely independent schools (as in New York, North Carolina, Ohio, and Rhode Island).

Follow the Stimulus Money

Read states鈥� Race to the Top applications and see state-by-state breakdowns of education funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. View this interactive map.

If any of those states wins, 鈥淚 think it could be potentially harmful to the administration鈥檚 rhetoric up until now, and the role of charters in education reform policy,鈥� said Mr. Ziebarth, who is the vice president of state advocacy for the Washington-based group.

Up next for the finalists is a high-pressure, in-person presentation to the peer reviewers who scored their applications, which will help determine whether they walk away with up to an estimated $700 million each, or nothing.

One big question mark will be how much money the winners receive collectively. The 16, together, asked for $6.5 billion, which would break the Race to the Top bank. All but Pennsylvania asked for more money than the maximum the 91制片厂视频 Department had suggested, which varied according to a state鈥檚 size.

The presentations, scheduled to be held next week in Washington, will be closed to the public, but will be videotaped and posted online once the winners are announced in April. Also to be made public at that time are the winning and losing states鈥� scores and the peer reviewers鈥� comments.

Any state, except a first-round winner, can submit an application for round two of the competition in June, with the final Race to the Top dollars to be awarded in September.

Some Surprises

Among the surprise appearances on the list: New York, which, on the day it submitted , failed to advance a legislative proposal that would have expanded the number of charter schools in the state. The state also has a law, which is set to sunset this summer, that bars the use of standardized-test-score data in tenure-granting decisions, though the data could, presumably, be used in annual teacher evaluations.

Many consider New York to be flouting the requirement that states, in order to be eligible to compete, have no firewall barring the use of student-achievement data in teacher-evaluation decisions.

Joe Williams, the executive director of Democrats for 91制片厂视频 Reform, a New York City-based political action committee, called New York鈥檚 appearance on the list 鈥渂affling.鈥�

Another dark-horse surprise was South Carolina.

鈥淎 lot of people thought we were a very, very long shot,鈥� said Jim Rex, South Carolina鈥檚 state schools superintendent. 鈥淲e are sort of like the little tugboat or the little train that could.鈥�

He said the state was 鈥渧iewed by a lot of people as an outsider鈥� in part because it wasn鈥檛 chosen by the Seattle-based Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation for a technical-assistance grant to help complete .

Only two of the 16 finalists鈥擲outh Carolina and 鈥攄id not pass Gates鈥� litmus test for $250,000 in aid to hire consultants.

The Sweet Sixteen

SOURCE: 91制片厂视频 Week staff writers Dakarai I. Aarons, Catherine Gewertz, Alyson Klein, Lesli A. Maxwell, Michele McNeil, and Stephen Sawchuk

鈥淚 think what the reviewers saw in our application was a true sense of collaboration and cohesive reform initiatives,鈥� said Daniel Cruce, Delaware鈥檚 deputy secretary of education. He highlighted his state鈥檚 participation in a six-state effort that will require aggressive interventions in the lowest-performing schools, and its plans to hire 鈥渄ata coaches鈥� to work directly with teachers.

On the flip side, many observers say that Indiana鈥檚 omission from the list was also a surprise, especially given its ambitious, to build a statewide evaluation system that focuses not just on using data to inform teacher evaluations, but for compensation, tenure, and promotion decisions.

Tony Bennett, Indiana鈥檚 state superintendent of public instruction, said he was 鈥渜uite disappointed鈥� because he thought his state had embraced鈥攂etter than others鈥攖he major principles of the competition, including revamping teacher evaluations, improving alternative routes to teaching, and increasing high-quality charter schools.

鈥淚 am confused. I am surprised,鈥� Mr. Bennett said. 鈥淲e were told to be bold and aggressive. I think our plan characterizes that.鈥�

Mr. Bennett said Indiana officials likely would apply for round two, but not change the core of their plan: 鈥淲e鈥檙e going to do what I don鈥檛 think the federal administration did do鈥攚e鈥檙e going to do what we said.鈥�

Some officials in states that were shut out of the first round expressed reservations, however, about applying for round two.

Jack O鈥機onnell, California鈥檚 state schools chief, said he was unsure whether the state should try again. Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, a Republican, said in a press release that California was left off the finalist list because the state鈥檚 proposed reforms were not aggressive enough.

Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, a Republican who is seen as a likely presidential contender in 2012, is using his state鈥檚 first-round loss鈥攁lso a surprise to many education policy watchers鈥攖o take on the state鈥檚 teachers鈥� union.

鈥淚t鈥檚 hard to race to the top with an anchor tied to your leg,鈥� said Brian McClung, Mr. Pawlenty鈥檚 deputy chief of staff, who in a statement urged the state legislature to adopt charter school and teacher-merit-pay changes in the wake of the Race to the Top announcement.

Geographical Spread

States that made the cut are heavily centered on the East Coast and in the South鈥攐nly Colorado lies entirely west of the Mississippi River. The list of finalists leans Democratic: Eleven of the finalists have Democratic chief executives, including the mayor of the District of Columbia; five are controlled by Republicans. (Nationwide, Democrats hold a majority of governorships, at 27.)

Race to the Top prognosticators had heavily favored Tennessee, in part for its passage of legislation this year that mandates using student achievement as half of a teacher鈥檚 annual evaluation. Louisiana, Illinois, and Florida have also mandated that half of a teacher鈥檚 evaluation be based on growth in student achievement.

Tennessee also has the advantage of its existing 鈥渧alue added鈥� data system, which positions it ahead of other states in being able to tap student-achievement information to make decisions about instruction and teacher performance, and to track how well teacher-preparation programs are doing.

Tennessee Gov. Phil Bredesen, a Democrat who was able to secure bipartisan support for a package of legislation that included raising the statewide cap on charter schools, highlighted the formal declaration of all seven major gubernatorial candidates in the state to back the Race to the Top changes. The state included their signatures in .

鈥淚 think so much of the issue is just the ability to sustain these reforms through political changes,鈥� said Gov. Bredesen, who will leave office early next year because of term limits. 鈥淚 think we鈥檝e got a really believable program when we can show that, regardless of who is in political office, these reforms are going to move forward.鈥�

The governor will be on the Tennessee team that goes to Washington to pitch the state鈥檚 plan.

Paul G. Pastorek, the schools chief in , said that central to his state鈥檚 plan is teacher effectiveness, particularly the teacher evaluations the state will design to heavily weigh growth in student performance. The state is also one of six that will be part of a new $75 million initiative to turn around low-performing schools using strategies created by the Boston-based Mass Insight 91制片厂视频 and Research Institute. (鈥淭urnaround Project Signs Six States,鈥� Feb. 3, 2010.)

Regardless of how the final awards shake out, state policy advocates say the Race to the Top has already had impact.

Robin M. Steans, the executive director of Advance Illinois, a school reform group that helped state officials shape Illinois鈥� application, believes that state can already point to concrete accomplishments when it makes its case for the federal reviewers.

One, she said, is state officials鈥� approval of the outside organizations that have to serve as partners to districts on turning around low-performing schools. Another is the state鈥檚 passage of legislation to create rigorous teacher evaluations and to raise the cap on charter schools.

鈥淥ne of the things you want to do is keep the energy going, and this competition so far has helped us get a ton of things done here in Illinois,鈥� Ms. Steans said. 鈥淏eing named a finalist helps keep us going even more.鈥�

Staff Writer Alyson Klein contributed to this story.