91制片厂视频

Opinion
Special 91制片厂视频 Opinion

Finding the Right Reading Program

By Al Moore 鈥 October 12, 2011 6 min read
Reading tutor Al Moore (left) works with a high school freshman in his Alexandria, Va., office. Moore aims to identify effective reading programs for struggling students based on their individual needs.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Learning to read is probably the single most critical skill that a child will acquire in his or her lifetime. Yet we as educators have not fully mastered the art of ensuring that every child learns to read. Having spent nearly a decade treating students with learning disabilities, reading disorders, dyslexia, autism, anxiety, and ADHD, and designing reading interventions that have been used in schools, I recognize there鈥檚 no silver bullet to fixing a reading problem.

But I also believe that there are things any teacher can do to select a good reading intervention and get struggling readers started on the path to reading success. Here are a few keys to doing just that:

Clarify What You Mean by 鈥淩eading Problem.鈥

Are you talking about students who can鈥檛 figure out the words on the page (fluency), or students who can鈥檛 make sense of the material they are reading (comprehension)? If it鈥檚 a fluency issue, does the problem stem from an inability to sound out and decode unknown words (phonemic awareness)? Or does the problem seem to be a sluggish reading rate and a poor ability to quickly recall words on sight (graphemic imagery)? If it鈥檚 a comprehension issue, is the problem with absorbing the details and making connections (receptive), or with retelling鈥攊n writing or orally鈥攖hat information in a logically connected, organized way (expressive)?

BRIC ARCHIVE

You probably don鈥檛 have all the answers to these questions, and that鈥檚 OK. Just asking them at all will help you gain a clearer understanding of the sort of challenges you鈥檙e up against鈥 and that鈥檚 the first step in choosing a good reading program for your students.

Know the Signs That Can Help Identify the Type of Reading Problem.

If you鈥檙e having trouble determining the type of reading deficit your students are experiencing, take a look at the indicators shown in the below chart. Recognizing these signs can give you an early indication of which support strategy will be most effective for your group.

Indicators of Reading Deficits

Indicator >
Consonant or vowel sound errors; poor ability to sound out words; and difficulty with phonetic spelling
Type of reading deficit >
Fluency (Phonemic awareness)

Indicator >
Accurate but slow reading; small sightword base; difficulty spelling; and frequent miscues, substitutions, or omissions
Type of reading deficit >
Fluency (Graphemic Imagery)

Indicator >
Inability to recall details, determine the main idea, make connections, draw conclusions, and understand and execute instructions
Type of reading deficit >
Comprehension (Receptive)

Indicator >
Disorganized recall of details; omission of important details when summarizing; relative strength in multiple-choice format; inconsistent ability to make connections and draw conclusions
Type of reading deficit >
Comprehension (Expressive)

Keep in mind that students can have a single reading deficit or a dual one, where they exhibit a combination of more than one type of reading problem. When this happens, it鈥檚 best to target one deficit at a time, rather than attempting to correct everything in one fell swoop.

Find an Assessment-Guided Approach.

An effective reading program includes exercises that target the specific reading deficit that needs improvement. Accordingly, it should start with some sort of diagnostic measure to help you identify that deficit. Ignoring this step is to assume that all reading challenges are the same, and that intervention is simply a matter of figuring out what skills have not been mastered and then re-teaching them.

Good diagnostic measures account for the variant types of reading deficits. For example, the diagnostic can help determine whether there is a fluency and comprehension problem (dual deficit), or a fluency problem that is limiting comprehension (single deficit). A thorough diagnostic measure can also give an indication of whether the cause of the reading deficit is instructional or cognitive in nature. If the cause is instructional, then some factor鈥攁 prolonged illness and absence from school, or a previously undiagnosed case of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder鈥攈as caused gaps in specific content knowledge. If the reading deficit is cognitive, the problem is caused by the way the brain processes information. In general, cognitive deficits require a more in-depth treatment approach, with a longer duration and greater intervention frequency.

If the reading program doesn鈥檛 include an assessment tool, there are some great independent ones available. The Phonological Awareness Test 2 (LinguiSystems), the Wide Range Achievement Test (PAR), and the Woodcock-Johnson are just a few of the tests that can be used in an effective assessment-guided approach.

Look for Cognitive-Based Exercises.

Whether the reading deficit is instructional or cognitive, fluency-based or comprehension-based, it鈥檚 a good idea to incorporate cognition exercises into the intervention. Cognition exercises improve reading by strengthening the brain鈥檚 ability to process information and function. Interestingly, the cognition exercises you can use to improve reading may not be reading activities at all.

For instance, there鈥檚 a neat little card game called On the Dot that can be used as a cognitive exercise. The game improves visual perception and spatial reasoning鈥攂oth of which are cognitive processes鈥攂y having players stack and align the images on semi-transparent cards. This sort of activity can strengthen visual acuity, which helps to reduce the number of reading substitutions (miscues) and line skips a student makes.

Many off-the-shelf programs include cognition exercises. For example, Seeing Stars, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes鈥 fluency program, asks students to visualize real and nonsense words and then transpose, add, delete, or substitute letters to make new words. This helps students practice maintaining a strong, stable mental image of an orthographic pattern鈥攕o strong that they can manipulate it and still recall it afterward.

If a program does not include a cognitive component, you can do cognition exercises or activities with your class and reap the benefits. For example, the game Guess Who also stimulates cognition and helps with comprehension. The objective of the game is to guess your opponent鈥檚 character by asking questions about the character鈥檚 looks and eliminating those that don鈥檛 fit the description. For students who struggle with comprehension or listening to and following directions, Guess Who reinforces auditory processing, short term memory, and decision-making. With increasing ability in these areas, students can more easily connect details in a passage, get the big picture, and recall information. Memory, the card game in which you have to flip over and match identical pictures, is another example. Practicing the identification and recall of visual images helps to strengthen those same processes in identifying and recalling letters and letter patterns.

Reading Programs

WILSON Reading System
Deficits Addressed: Fluency, Comprehension
Features: Multi-sensory program; leveled library for controlled student reading; individualized materials; includes a program assessment

Phono-Graphix
Deficits Addressed: Fluency
Features: Visual-based instruction; reinforces segmentation, blending, and phonemic awareness

Seeing Stars, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
Deficits Addressed: Fluency
Features: Singular emphasis on fluency; leveled materials and workbooks; multi-sensory feedback; good for students needing intensive intervention; includes cognitive exercises

The Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing Program (LiPS), Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
Deficits Addressed: Fluency (phonemic)
Features: Strong emphasis on phonics; leveled materials and workbooks; multi-sensory feedback; good for students needing intensive intervention; includes cognitive exercises

Visualizing and Verbalizing (V/V), Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
Deficits Addressed: Comprehension
Features: Singular emphasis on comprehension; leveled workbooks; multi-sensory feedback; good for students needing intensive intervention; includes cognitive exercises

Fast ForWord Literacy
Deficits Addressed: Fluency, Comprehension
Features: Computer-based instruction; user-adaptive software; tracking and reporting features; primary and secondary instructional delineations; includes cognitive exercises

Reading Horizons
Deficits Addressed: Fluency
Features: Systematic instruction; visual marking methodology for reinforcement; reading software available on computer; teacher-friendly tools to facilitate classroom use

Cognitive Reading Strategies
Deficits Addressed: Fluency, Comprehension
Features: Combined decoding, comprehension, and writing strategies; program assessment and cognitive exercises included

Without the proper emphasis on cognition, we assume by default that students primarily need to hear the information again. And that鈥檚 essentially all that鈥檚 done in some cases: a re-telling of the same information, perhaps in a more interesting way or with an improved support plan. Dynamic instruction is important. A systematic support plan is important as well. But if the cause of the reading deficit is cognitive, then the emphasis must be on implementing cognition exercises that will stimulate the brain to engage and process the concepts in a new manner. Without it, we fool ourselves about the effectiveness of our strategies and fail to maximize the potential of our students. We become like the instructor who replies to his pupil鈥檚 confusion not by providing further insight and clarity, but by repeating his initial explanation in a louder voice.

If you need to supplement an intervention program with more cognition exercises, a great place to find activities is Marbles: The Brain Store. Marbles has a variety of cognitive games, activities, and software that can strengthen processing skills. Look for activities that stimulate visual or auditory memory, processing speed, visual or auditory attention, decision speed, or auditory discrimination, as these are cognitive processes that undergird strong reading skills.

Select an Appropriate Research-Based Reading Program That Brings Together Elements of Strong Reading Intervention.

If you鈥檙e still not sure what kinds of reading programs I鈥檓 referring to, some examples are provided in the accompanying chart. Keep in mind that these programs can be expensive and that some require more extensive professional development than others.

Choosing a good program is about fit. It is better to identify student need and match a program from there than it is to choose a program just because it has cognition exercises and an assessment-guided approach. Remember, you鈥檙e not searching for the perfect program鈥攜ou鈥檙e searching for the perfect program for your students. Hopefully these tips will help you do just that.

A version of this article appeared in the October 13, 2011 edition of Teacher PD Sourcebook as Finding the RIGHT Reading Program

Events

Recruitment & Retention Webinar Keep Talented Teachers and Improve Student Outcomes
Keep talented teachers and unlock student success with strategic planning based on insights from Apple 91制片厂视频 and educational leaders.鈥
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 91制片厂视频 Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Family Engagement: The Foundation for a Strong School Year
Learn how family engagement promotes student success with insights from National PTA, AASA鈥痑nd leading districts and schools.鈥
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 91制片厂视频 Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Special 91制片厂视频 Webinar
How Early Adopters of Remote Therapy are Improving IEPs
Learn how schools are using remote therapy to improve IEP compliance & scalability while delivering outcomes comparable to onsite providers.
Content provided by 

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Special 91制片厂视频 How Much Does Special 91制片厂视频 Truly Cost? Finally, an Answer Is on the Horizon
A new federally funded research study will provide the first national assessment in 25 years of spending on students with disabilities.
10 min read
Budget analysis calculator, data, budget sheet.
iStock/Getty
Special 91制片厂视频 Sudden Fame for Tim Walz's Son Brings Attention to Non-Verbal Learning Disorder
Searches on Google spiked for the the teen鈥檚 name and non-verbal learning disorder.
4 min read
Democratic vice presidential nominee Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz hugs his son Gus during the Democratic National Convention Wednesday, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago.
Democratic vice presidential nominee Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz hugs his son Gus during the Democratic National Convention Wednesday, Aug. 21, 2024, in Chicago.
Erin Hooley/AP
Special 91制片厂视频 Opinion This Is My Reality as a Student With Dyslexia
A high schooler reflects on what teachers should know to make school better for students with learning differences.
Maxwell J. Lesny
4 min read
A man in a maze, concept idea art of lost solution and problem, surreal mystery painting, conceptual artwork, 3d illustration
Jorm Sangsorn/iStock + 91制片厂视频 Week
Special 91制片厂视频 AI's Potential in Special 91制片厂视频: What Teachers and Parents Think
A report examines parents' and educators' perspectives on AI use for students with disabilities.
3 min read
 Illustration of artificial intelligence and motherboard in the shape of a lightbulb with two head profiles on either side, both containing circuit imagery inside and a female sitting on top of one working on a laptop.
DigitalVision Vector