91制片厂视频

Opinion
Teaching Opinion

It鈥檚 Time to Focus on the Forgotten Middle

By Mary Catherine Swanson 鈥 November 01, 2005 5 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Barbara Kiwak

BRIC ARCHIVE

Hearing that 鈥渁ll the children are above average鈥 in Garrison Keillor鈥檚 fictional town of Lake Wobegon elicits a knowing chuckle, not just because it鈥檚 a mathematical impossibility, but also because most of us think our own children are special. No one wants to be considered 鈥渁verage,鈥 even if you鈥檙e often in good company.

But this aversion is one reason we neglect average students in education. In recent years, our focus on the top and bottom has become more glaring, and we have largely ignored the vast middle in our schools. We鈥檝e returned to a tracking system by default.

See Also

Live Web chat: Join us on Wed., Nov. 9, 2 p.m., ET, for a with the author of this Commentary on the topic of the 鈥渇orgotten middle,鈥 those students students who attend school regularly, rarely say anything, don鈥檛 cause trouble, and get by with mediocre grades. Who鈥檚 looking out for them?

.

Who are these forgotten-middle students? Generally, they鈥檙e the silent majority鈥攖he kids who come to school regularly, sit in the back of the class, rarely say anything, don鈥檛 cause trouble, and get by with C鈥檚. They are not failing, nor are they the math whiz or star pupil. They are nearly invisible. Their parents and teachers are content that they are making it through and no alarm bells are going off.

They constitute a large part of the middle two quartiles of students. They鈥檒l graduate, but won鈥檛 be prepared for college. And many of them will wander around for years in dead-end jobs.

It鈥檚 time to re-energize the discussion on how to serve those 鈥渁verage鈥 students. Today, we鈥檙e consigning millions of students to low expectations, ignoring their true potential, and denying them the education they need to get ahead. Schools are not making the achievement gains they could. And we鈥檙e contributing to greater economic and racial polarization in our country, while failing to address national workforce and economic realities.

The persistent and growing divide we saw so vividly following Hurricane Katrina鈥攖housands of people, predominantly African-American, trapped by floodwaters and poverty鈥攅xists nationwide. For moral and economic reasons, no society should condone this unconscionably extreme division of its people鈥檚 access to opportunity.

Making every child college-ready must start with giving students a clear sense of what they need to do to succeed.

The economic consequences of ignoring the middle majority of our students are sobering. The lifetime earnings of a typical college graduate are close to $1 million more than those of someone with only a high school diploma. And the education-related income gap is widening. In the 1990s, real earnings for workers with a bachelor鈥檚 degree rose at three times the rate of high school graduates鈥 wages. The differing prospects of getting and keeping a job also are striking: The unemployment rate among college graduates is about half the rate for high school graduates.

Beyond the individual income potential, our society and the nation鈥檚 economy pay a price as well. While China and India surge ahead, and a quarter of the scientists and engineers in U.S. research and product development today are foreign-born, so few American students are going into science and engineering that business leaders are calling for doubling the number of Americans with degrees in these disciplines. Yet we restrict our search for a solution to the thin slice of highest achievers. Instead, we should introduce more students to such coursework, motivate and support them, and create a bigger pool going into these fields.

Likewise, we lament that our college campuses are getting less diverse as our society gets more diverse. But we neglect first-generation college students, minority students, and lower-income students.

Today, our school policies focus on the top and bottom quartiles to the exclusion of the huge middle. Federal programs are aimed at either gifted and talented students or special-needs and at-risk kids. The two ends of the spectrum understandably have demanding and costly needs, but they have gotten most of the attention and money.

As well-meaning as the goals of the federal No Child Left Behind Act may be, the law exacerbates this imbalance by focusing on basic skills and failing schools, not whether students are college-ready. Tutoring dollars go to low-income students in schools that are making insufficient progress. In essence, it鈥檚 a retracking program focused on the academic bottom.

What鈥檚 needed is an untracking program that makes college-readiness for all students, including the forgotten middle, a paramount goal and a strategy for improvement. We must start by abandoning the mind-set that labels so many students as not being college material. The expectation ought to be that all students, with few exceptions, will complete the rigorous course loads needed to get into a four-year college.

Not everyone will get a college degree, but having acquired essential skills and knowledge, students will be better off, whether they go to college, receive other training, or go right into the workforce. Employers, after all, are demanding the same critical-thinking, math, and communications skills required by college-admissions officers.

Making every child college-ready must start with giving students a clear sense of what they need to do to succeed. Most 9th graders say they want to go to college. But in two or three years, having remained forgotten in the background, most won鈥檛 have taken the courses necessary to gain admission.

Addressing the needs of the forgotten middle isn鈥檛 just a nice thing to do. Our nation鈥檚 economic and moral position in the world depends on how effectively we respond to this challenge.

Raising achievement requires challenging our students to take more rigorous classes and providing the support they need to do so. Classes that stretch and stimulate the mind bring out the best in students. They rise to the challenge and become more driven and more focused. U.S. Department of 91制片厂视频 research shows that a rigorous curriculum is the best preparation for college success, especially for Latino and African-American students. That鈥檚 why colleges routinely place greater value on a C-plus grade in an Advanced Placement course than on a B-plus in a run-of-the-mill class.

But students need support to make it. That鈥檚 especially true for those whose parents didn鈥檛 go to college, who come from homes where English is a second language, or who face obstacles related to poverty. The support structures must be tailored to the different needs of individual students, and cannot be optional. They must be part of the regular school day, where they鈥檒l be a core part of learning and be recognized as essential.

We know that students can do it. Ninety-five percent of the students served by the Advancement Via Individual Determination, or AVID, program have gone on to college, enrolling at three times the rate of students without the rigor-and-support approach.

They show that Garrison Keillor鈥檚 description of the children of Lake Wobegon is not really off. Most of the forgotten-middle students are really above average. We simply have defined our expectations and requirements for them too low. By raising the bar, instead of lowering it, and by providing the necessary support, we can ensure that students graduate ready to fulfill their potential.

Addressing the needs of the forgotten middle isn鈥檛 just a nice thing to do. Increasingly, our nation鈥檚 economic and moral position in the world depends on how effectively we respond to this challenge.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the November 02, 2005 edition of 91制片厂视频 Week as It鈥檚 Time to Focus On the Forgotten Middle

Events

Recruitment & Retention Webinar Keep Talented Teachers and Improve Student Outcomes
Keep talented teachers and unlock student success with strategic planning based on insights from Apple 91制片厂视频 and educational leaders.鈥
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 91制片厂视频 Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Family Engagement: The Foundation for a Strong School Year
Learn how family engagement promotes student success with insights from National PTA, AASA鈥痑nd leading districts and schools.鈥
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 91制片厂视频 Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Special 91制片厂视频 Webinar
How Early Adopters of Remote Therapy are Improving IEPs
Learn how schools are using remote therapy to improve IEP compliance & scalability while delivering outcomes comparable to onsite providers.
Content provided by 

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Teaching Opinion 鈥楶eople Can Only Hear When They鈥檙e Heard': Navigating Divisive Conversations
M贸nica Guzm谩n offers advice to educators on teaching themselves and their students how to use curiosity to navigate divisive conversations.
1 min read
Teaching Quiz QUIZ: Can You Spot the False Claims About Learning and the Brain?
Test your knowledge of common facts and myths about learning science.
1 min read
Thoughts and options head with arrows
iStock/Getty
Teaching Opinion Giving Up Control in the Classroom Can Be Scary. Student Agency Is Worth It
Student agency offers many benefits, says a former high school band director.
Sarah Bost
5 min read
Vibrant colored illustration of teen girl with bass guitar holding camera taking selfie with her friends at music class with a cacophony of musical iconography surrounding them.
Vanessa Solis/91制片厂视频 Week + iStock/Getty Images
Teaching Opinion 'Equality' and 'Equity' Are Different. But in Thriving Schools, They Coexist
Equity benefits the entire school community, even if it's met with resistance by some.
10 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
iStock/Getty