When the bell rings at Wheaton North High School, a river of white students flows into Advanced Placement classrooms. A trickle of brown and black students joins them. But mostly, the Latino, African-American, and Asian teenagers file into lower-rung classes.
In this way, Wheaton North is like thousands of other high schools across the country, replicating along its polished hallways the inequities that mark the daily lives of minority and low-income students beyond the school鈥檚 big glass doors. Studies show, in fact, that achievement gaps within schools can be greater than those from school to school.
And, like many schools nationwide, Wheaton North is trying hard to rewire the machinery that perpetuates those inequities. It鈥檚 making progress, but entrenched patterns persist.
鈥淲e鈥檙e trying to make this school work for everybody,鈥� said Matt Biscan, who鈥檚 in his third year as principal at Wheaton North. 鈥淲hat that means, exactly, we鈥檙e figuring out as we go.鈥�
Hidden Inequities: An 91制片厂视频 Week Analysis
Educators and the public are aware that achievement gaps often separate students of color from their higher-achieving white peers and leave low-income students lagging behind their better-off peers. Less obvious are the mechanisms and circumstances that contribute to those academic differences鈥攐ften within a single school.
This article is the first of a series intended to shed light on the 鈥渉idden inequities鈥� that keep education from reaching the goal of leveling the playing field for all students.
Each installment is being produced by 91制片厂视频 Week staff writers working in collaboration with the 91制片厂视频 Week Research Center.
For this first installment, the research center mined national data to pinpoint high-achieving schools鈥擶heaton North High School ranks in the top 20 percent nationwide for its high participation rate in Advanced Placement classes鈥攖hat also have race- and income-based disparities in who takes those classes.
Future installments will continue to draw on data analyses to examine:
- How parents and donors effectively鈥攁nd sometimes unwittingly鈥攖ip the educational equity scales in public schools through private contributions and advocacy (April);
- District-to-district disparities in disciplinary practices used with special education students (May) and;
- School closings and high student-mobility rates, their impact on educational quality, and their disparate effects on different school communities (June).
Click here to read the full series.
One thing it means is a big push to open the doors of AP classrooms to everyone, not just the white, affluent students who disproportionately fill those chairs. That work is complex, slow-moving, and far from finished.
At tables in the sunny lunchtime commons, brown, black, and white students offer many stories of counselors and teachers who encourage them to try higher-level classes. But that sense of freedom and support isn鈥檛 universal.
鈥淭hey don鈥檛 treat people the same,鈥� said an African-American girl who declined to give her name, even though she takes AP classes.
鈥淭hey kind of size you up, like if they think you鈥檙e going to a four-year college, they鈥檙e like, 鈥楢P鈥檚 hard, but keep trying.鈥� If they think you鈥檙e maybe just going to community college, it鈥檚 more like, 鈥楽ure, if AP鈥檚 too hard, don鈥檛 do it.鈥� 鈥�
Three white boys eating lunch nearby said their 8th grade teachers suggested that they try AP classes, but since they鈥檝e been at Wheaton North, no one has mentioned it. Instead, they鈥檙e taking classes that are mostly in the school鈥檚 lowest tier of rigor.
Axel Muro had a different experience. The child of Mexican immigrants, the 16-year-old said he earned good grades in the least difficult tier of classes and decided to try an AP history class at his teacher鈥檚 suggestion.
Even with a special school-provided summer course for support, though, it proved too tough, and Muro dropped out after one semester. 鈥淭hey expect you to do it all on your own, and it was, like, so much reading, I couldn鈥檛 do it,鈥� he said. A half-dozen of his friends have done the same, he said.
Those kinds of stories make Biscan grind his teeth. As the principal, he鈥檚 leading the push to change long-standing patterns that have sifted and sorted these 2,100 students鈥� opportunities by race, income, and family background.
He鈥檚 leading that drive in a predominantly white, affluent Chicago suburb known for its churches and civility, where immigrants from Burma, Mexico, and Iran are expanding the notion of community daily.
In a high school that鈥檚 one of America鈥檚 best, according to national magazines, but where students from the humble brick apartment buildings south of the railroad tracks often feel out of place in advanced classes. A school where the nearly all-white teaching staff politely sidesteps conversations about racial equity, even as they try to build an academic playing field where all students can win.
Beneath the Surface
The patterns here aren鈥檛 easy to budge. Some are published, for all to see, in school report cards.
Black, Hispanic and low-income students score much lower on state tests here, as they do in schools nationwide. More than a quarter of Wheaton North students take AP classes鈥攁n accomplishment that puts the school in rarefied air nationally. But only 16 percent of those seats hold minority students, even though nonwhites make up 31 percent of the student body.
A fuller picture of students鈥� lives and opportunities emerges from things that aren鈥檛 on school report cards. Whether students are in regular or advanced classes. The grades they earn. The clubs they join and the sports they play. How likely they are to be suspended or apply to college.
At Wheaton North, there are three levels of classes: intermediate, or 鈥淚-levels,鈥� the default track, yet still considered college-prep; advanced, or 鈥淎-levels,鈥� and Advanced Placement. Low-income and minority students are overrepresented in I-level classes and underrepresented in AP classes.
Minority and low-income students are more likely to be suspended, and they鈥檙e twice as likely to fail a class as their white peers. And even though more than 8 in 10 minority students here apply to college, they鈥檙e far more likely to choose two-year colleges than their wealthier, white peers.
Wheaton North started work to change those patterns six years ago by dropping its lowest track of classes: remedial.
鈥淚f you walked into an R-level class, it was 75 to 80 percent minorities, kids from low socioeconomic backgrounds,鈥� said English teacher Nicole Blazier. 鈥淭he high concentration of kids with weak skills just wasn鈥檛 right for those kids.鈥�
Knowing those students would need extra support in a default college-prep curriculum, the school established a co-teaching system. A teacher of special education or English-learners joins a regular teacher in all core I-level courses that include students with disabilities, those learning English, and those with weaker skills.
On a recent afternoon, Blazier and special education teacher Ellen Murphy held a Socratic dialogue on The Great Gatsby with their 25 students. As in most I-level classes, this one had more than its share of minority students. Sitting in two concentric circles, the students debated the classic novel. The two teachers facilitated a lively discussion that involved everyone.
These co-taught classes have opened pathways for students. The A-level classes are swelling with teenagers who came from co-taught rooms.
鈥淭hat鈥檚 the idea,鈥� Biscan said. 鈥淭o provide that support so they can move up. And we see that happening.鈥�
Raising Its Sights
A centerpiece of Wheaton North鈥檚 work is its new AP Inspiring Excellence program. Last year, administrators gathered to analyze students鈥� grades, PSAT scores, and attendance to identify those who might do well in AP. They sent the list to teachers and asked for feedback.
The form was deliberately designed to make it hard for teachers to say no. Their only response options are to recommend a student for AP, recommend a student on the condition that he or she takes a summer 鈥渂ridge鈥� class, or offer explanations.
Multiple teacher recommendations triggered a conference in the main office.
Eva Barg, a senior who鈥檚 white, remembers the day she was called down to the office. She鈥檇 lurked below the radar for two years, trying not to draw attention in I-level classes.
But the vote of confidence she got in the meeting, where she learned of her teachers鈥� recommendations, felt like a lightning bolt.
鈥淚t changed the way I thought about myself,鈥� Eva said. 鈥淚 thought I wasn鈥檛 as smart as everyone else.鈥�
She took the school鈥檚 three-week summer bridge program to prepare students for AP and got an A in AP English her junior year. A huge smile spreads across her face as she tells this story. Now, she鈥檚 taking two more AP classes.
Summer bridge is a key weapon as Wheaton North tries to shatter old class-taking patterns. For three weeks, three hours a day, students work on academic skills and study habits. Counselors hand-schedule those students into AP classes with the same teachers they had in summer bridge.
鈥淭hey try to be sensitive to [students鈥橾 comfort level when they鈥檙e trying it for the first time,鈥� said James Butikofer, who teaches AP psychology and its corresponding summer bridge course.
Wheaton North piloted a summer bridge class in English for five years before expanding the idea to seven courses in 2016.
The layers of support, however, can鈥檛 always erase the feeling of otherness that can reduce students鈥� inclination to sign up for advanced classes.
鈥淚鈥檓 the only one in my AP class, and it鈥檚 intimidating,鈥� said one black student. 鈥淢y I-levels are more mixed, so I feel more comfortable in those classes.鈥�
Freedom to Choose
Even as racial inequity persists, Wheaton North has managed to foster an atmosphere of academic fluidity. It鈥檚 easy to find students with white, brown, or black faces who鈥檒l tell you proudly that they moved from I-levels to A-levels or AP, or that their counselor keeps nagging them to do so. They also feel free to move down a rung if they wish.
Katlyn Jackson, an African-American sophomore, is taking I-level classes now but is thinking about moving up next year.
鈥淚 feel like you have a lot of choices here, and some you didn鈥檛 know you had,鈥� she said. 鈥淚f you feel you鈥檙e in a place where this is the class I want to take, people at Wheaton North challenge you and can make that happen.鈥�
Warisha Aslam, who immigrated from Pakistan in 8th grade, chose mostly A-level courses in high school. The 12th grader has had to work hard to get good grades, but she said the jump into AP classes 鈥渨as the best decision I ever made.鈥� Her teachers have been universally helpful and supportive when she hit rough patches.
Wheaton North defies some national patterns that perpetuate inequity. It doesn鈥檛 concentrate its least-experienced teachers in classes with the neediest students. All teachers teach a range of lower-level and higher-level courses.
Its graduation requirements reflect the admissions requirements for Illinois state-university campuses. Diploma requirements that fall short of state-university expectations can become stumbling blocks, especially for students whose college aspirations take shape later than those of their peers.
But in other ways, the school echoes nationwide inequities.
Students can choose to spend their mornings at a nearby regional career-and-technical-education center. Its 20 programs of study offer hands-on learning that leads to jobs, industry certificates, or college.
Those programs provide earnings and postsecondary possibilities for young people who wouldn鈥檛 otherwise have them. Eighty percent of the students at the regional center go on to college; nearly half of those attend four-year universities.
But racial- and income-based patterns here are impossible to miss. The bus that brings students to this sprawling complex from Wheaton North has a much bigger share of minority and low-income students on it than the campus they left behind. Some of the programs with lower earnings potential, such as early-childhood education, are nearly filled with minority girls, while those with higher income potential, such as engineering, are dominated by white male faces.
At the Wheaton North campus, teachers are reluctant to discuss race- and income-based patterns in school life, which can hinder the conversations necessary to uncover and solve the problems.
Asked about those patterns in I-level, A-level, and AP classes, most teachers chose to recast the question, saying they prefer to be colorblind, tailoring support to students based on their academic or emotional needs, not their race or class.
Stumbling Blocks
An outdated student-data system also hobbles the school鈥檚 efforts to investigate and track key indicators of trouble or progress.
Teachers don鈥檛 have easy access to disaggregated data on coursetaking, college applications, and other dynamics that are influenced by race and income. Administrators had to funnel enormous effort into assembling the data in response to a reporter鈥檚 request.
It鈥檚 just one more source of frustration for Biscan as his team works to identify and address inequities in their school.
And yet, it was an analysis of student data several years ago that launched Wheaton North on its path to move overlooked students into challenging classes.
One of the most elusive and difficult challenges in that work lies with students themselves, the educators here say. Some can鈥檛 take on tougher classes because they have to work or help out at home.
But others decline because they don鈥檛 have time in schedules crammed with sports or activities, they have too many hard classes already, or aren鈥檛 confident they can handle tougher courses, said Robert Longenbaugh, who directs the school鈥檚 seven-member team of counselors.
Marc Anderson hears something more in that 鈥渃onfidence鈥� reason. As a black man, and a Wheaton North social worker attuned to the stories of students of color, Anderson hears doubts and fears begging to be chased away by adults with high expectations.
鈥淭here鈥檚 a mindset that you鈥檙e not good enough, or smart enough, that takes shape in elementary school and persists through high school, and kids buy into it,鈥� Anderson said. 鈥淲e鈥檙e the ones that have to help them see things differently.鈥�
That journey is far from over, and educators at Wheaton North aren鈥檛 exactly sure how they鈥檒l know when they can mark their arrival. Is it when their AP classes precisely replicate their student demographics? Or something short of that?
鈥淪aying that all kids need to get to the same place by the time they leave, that isn鈥檛 the right idea,鈥� said science teacher Rachelle Terada. 鈥淭hey should be better when they leave, better than they thought they could be. Is that the same for every kid? I don鈥檛 know.鈥�
Math teacher Anne Gentzler sees it this way: 鈥淚t鈥檚 that age-old debate: Where does each kid end up, and is that enough?鈥�
Biscan, for his part, is still wrestling with that question. He knows that many families aren鈥檛 yearning for their students to conquer AP and attend a university. His community has many, varied goals for its children. And he knows that for now, that has to mean more open doors.
